Yes, this is who we are: America’s 250-year history of political violence

theconversation.com/yes-this-i…

gopher://magical.fish/0/news/theconversation/2025/09/2025-09-12 20-44-33 Yes this is who we are-Americas 250-year history of political violence

© The Conversation
This story was originally published by The Conversation and is unaltered.

Published and © by The Conversation
Content appears here under this condition or license: Creative Commons CC BY-ND 4.0.

. . . . . . . . . .

[‘Maurizio Valsania’]

Date: 2025-09-12 20:44:33+00:00

The day after conservative activist Charlie Kirk was shot and killed while speaking at Utah Valley University, commentators repeated a familiar refrain: “This isn’t who we are as Americans.”

Others similarly weighed in. Whoopi Goldberg on “The View” declared that Americans solve political disagreements peacefully: “This is not the way we do it.”

Yet other awful episodes come immediately to mind: President John F. Kennedy was shot and killed on Nov. 22, 1963. More recently, on June 14, 2025, Melissa Hortman, speaker emerita of the Minnesota House of Representatives, was shot and killed at her home, along with her husband and their golden retriever.

As a historian of the early republic, I believe that seeing this violence in America as distinct “episodes” is wrong.

Instead, they reflect a recurrent pattern.

American politics has long personalized its violence. Time and again, history’s advance has been imagined to depend on silencing or destroying a single figure – the rival who becomes the ultimate, despicable foe.

Hence, to claim that such shootings betray “who we are” is to forget that the U.S. was founded upon – and has long been sustained by – this very form of political violence.

Revolutionary violence as political theater

The years of the American Revolution were incubated in violence. One abominable practice used on political adversaries was tarring and feathering. It was a punishment imported from Europe and popularized by the Sons of Liberty in the late 1760s, Colonial activists who resisted British rule.

In seaport towns such as Boston and New York, mobs stripped political enemies, usually suspected loyalists – supporters of British rule – or officials representing the king, smeared them with hot tar, rolled them in feathers, and paraded them through the streets.

The effects on bodies were devastating. As the tar was peeled away, flesh came off in strips. People would survive the punishment, but they would carry the scars for the rest of their life.

By the late 1770s, the Revolution in what is known as the Middle Colonies had become a brutal civil war. In New York and New Jersey, patriot militias, loyalist partisans and British regulars raided across county lines, targeting farms and neighbors. When patriot forces captured loyalist irregulars – often called “Tories” or “refugees” – they frequently treated them not as prisoners of war but as traitors, executing them swiftly, usually by hanging.

In September 1779, six loyalists were caught near Hackensack, New Jersey. They were hanged without trial by patriot militia. Similarly, in October 1779, two suspected Tory spies captured in the Hudson Highlands were shot on the spot, their execution justified as punishment for treason.

To patriots, these killings were deterrence; to loyalists, they were murder. Either way, they were unmistakably political, eliminating enemies whose “crime” was allegiance to the wrong side.

Pistols at dawn: Dueling as politics

Even after independence, the workings of American politics remained grounded in a logic of violence toward adversaries.

For national leaders, the pistol duel was not just about honor. It normalized a political culture where gunfire itself was treated as part of the debate.

The most famous duel, of course, was Aaron Burr’s killing of Alexander Hamilton in 1804. But scores of lesser-known confrontations dotted the decade before it.

In 1798, Henry Brockholst Livingston – later a U.S. Supreme Court justice – killed James Jones in a duel. Far from discredited, he was deemed to have acted honorably. In the early republic, even homicide could be absorbed into politics when cloaked in ritual. Ironically, Livingston had survived an assassination attempt in 1785.

In 1802, another shameful spectacle unfolded: New York Democratic-Republicans DeWitt Clinton and John Swartwout faced off in Weehawken, New Jersey. They fired at least five rounds before their seconds intervened, leaving both men wounded. In this case, the clash had nothing to do with political principle; Clinton and Swartwout were Republicans. It was a patronage squabble that still erupted into gunfire, showing how normalized armed violence was in settling disputes.

Gun culture and its expansion

It is tempting to dismiss political violence as a leftover from some “primitive” or “frontier” stage of American history, when politicians and their supporters supposedly lacked restraint or higher moral standards. But that is not the case.

From before the Revolution onward, physical punishment or even killing were ways to enforce belonging, to mark the boundary between insiders and outsiders, and to decide who had the right to govern.

Violence has never been a distortion in American politics. It has been one of its recurring features, not an aberration but a persistent force, destructive and yet oddly creative, producing new boundaries and new regimes.

The dynamic only deepened as gun ownership expanded. In the 19th century, industrial arms production and aggressive federal contracts put more weapons into circulation. The rituals of punishing those with the wrong allegiance now found expression in the mass-produced revolver and later in the automatic rifle.

These more modern firearms became not only practical tools of war, crime or self-defense but symbolic objects in their own right. They embodied authority, carried cultural meaning and gave their holders the sense that legitimacy itself could be claimed at the barrel of a gun.

That’s why the phrase “This isn’t who we are” rings false. Political violence has always been part of America’s story, not a passing anomaly, and not an episode.

To deny it is to leave Americans defenseless against it. Only by facing this history head-on can Americans begin to imagine a politics not defined by the gun.

[END]

Url: theconversation.com/yes-this-i…

via Magical.Fish Gopher News Feeds:
gopher://magical.fish/1/feeds/news/theconversation/

#charlie-kirk #assassination #shooting #utah

Yes, this is who we are: America’s 250-year history of political violence

The US has long fused politics and violence, often through firearms. To claim that such shootings betray ‘who we are’ is to forget that the US was founded on this form of political violence.

^{The Conversation}

mastodon.social/@pomarede/1151… pomarede@mastodon.social - Snippets from a 360° panorama captured two days ago by Curiosity, including a new angle on the Yardang unit

#Mars Sep. 11, 2025 - Sol 4656
Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/MSSS

#Curiosity #rover #Sol4656 #CuriosityRover #GaleCrater #AeolisMons #yardangs #YardangUnit #space #science #STEM #geology #mastcam #mosaic #photography #Astrodon

Daniel Pomarède (@pomarede@mastodon.social)

Attached: 4 images Snippets from a 360° panorama captured two days ago by Curiosity, including a new angle on the Yardang unit #Mars Sep.

^Mastodon

Nazis on the march in London

Police say 110,000 attending ‘unite the kingdom’ rally in London, with some in crowd attacking officers – UK politics live theguardian.com/politics/live/…

Police say 110,000 attending ‘unite the kingdom’ rally in London, with some in crowd attacking officers – UK politics live

Met Police say ‘difficult to estimate numbers in attendance’ but they believe 110,000 attending rally, with one group in Whitehall throwing projectiles at officers

^{Amy Sedghi (The Guardian)}

wandering.shop/@Catvalente/115… Catvalente@wandering.shop - White-on-white crime is a tragic epidemic sweeping the country.

How many more will we lose to white gang violence and rightwing turf wars?

It’s the culture, you know.

These white celebrities glamorize a criminal lifestyle & young inner-suburb kids get trapped in the school-to-influencer pipeline.

Jobs I never knew existed.

thehustle.co/the-surreal-life-…

The surreal life of a professional bridesmaid

For the last decade, Jen Glantz has worked as a bridesmaid for hire. Her life is a romantic comedy waiting to happen.

^{Katherine Laidlaw (HubSpot)}

mastodon.cr/@Linux/11519407853… Linux@mastodon.cr - @eco_amandine

I have been developing a list of digital service providers outside U.S. jurisdiction.

Regarding VPNs, the list currently includes the following:

iVPN — Gibraltar, Europe (UK territory)
ivpn.net

Mullvad VPN — Sweden, Europe
mullvad.net

Goose VPN — Netherlands, Europe
goosevpn.com

Xeovo VPN — Finland, Europe
xeovo.com

Windscribe — Canada, North America
windscribe.com

French Data Network — France, Europe
vador.fdn.fr/souscription/vpn.…

I'm always looking to expand my list. You can find the full list of categories here: codeberg.org/Linux-Is-Best/Out…

Outside_US_Jurisdiction/Index.md at main

Outside_US_Jurisdiction - Digital Service Providers outside the jurisdiction of the United States of America.

^Codeberg.org

mastodon.cr/@Linux/11519398561… Linux@mastodon.cr - Proton Mail Falls Under U.S. Jurisdiction

If you read their Terms of Service, at first glance, they reference the laws of Switzerland. However, because they now have offices in the United States — along with registrations, trademarks, copyrights, and patents in the U.S. — they also cite U.S. laws. The only two countries you'll see mentioned are Switzerland and the United States — nothing else.

Their CEO has, on several occasions, also praised Donald Trump. Additionally, Proton left the Fediverse because they couldn’t silence users there as they have on platforms like Facebook or Reddit. The fact that they’re now trying to silence journalists doesn’t surprise me.

There are better alternatives to Proton Mail.

Tuta — Germany, Europe
tuta.com

Mailfence — Belgium, Europe
mailfence.com

Soverin — Netherlands, Europe
soverin.com

Startmail — Netherlands, Europe
startmail.com

Mailbox.org — Germany, Europe
mailbox.org

#Proton #ProtonMail #ProtonPass #ProtonVPN #ProtonWallet #ProtonDrive #ProtonCalendar #ProtonMeet #ProtonAuthenticator

Your data – under your control.

Your digital workspace with email, cloud, office & meet. Secure & GDPR-compliant for businesses, public authorities and private individuals. ▶ Try us now!

^mailbox

first the bees, now the earthworms

Officials issue warning amid concerning spread of toxic 'hammerhead worm': 'Don't squish or cut them'

Hammerhead worms feed primarily on earthworms. With few natural predators, hammerhead worms are able to entirely wipe out earthworm populations. Its toxic exterior can also be an irritant if humans or pets make contact with it. The Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife said hammerhead worms can impact native plant growth.

"Don't squish or cut them. That's how they multiply!" warned the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife.

Instead, they should be captured in a bag and frozen for 48 hours before being disposed of. They can also be drowned in soapy water. Witnesses are encouraged to report sightings to iNaturalist.

yahoo.com/news/articles/offici…

MAHA debunking

Are Raw Milk, Seed Oils, and Uncured Deli Meat Good for You? - Consumer Reports consumerreports.org/health/nut…

5 Misunderstood Foods

Confusion surrounds foods like raw milk, uncured deli meats, and seed oils. Consumer Reports provides the lowdown on whether or not they're good for you.

^{Consumer Reports}